Mystery Star Ornaments

Mystery Star Ornaments


Shipping to United States: $3.00

Who doesn't love surprises?! When you purchase a star ornament, you'll be sent a completely random color combo. It will be bold and bright and fun, guaranteed.

In a typical holiday season, I paint dozens of different designs since I'm at in-person markets. However, I'll only be selling virtually this season. This allows me to be creative without having to pay for several listings. Plus! It's a fun surprise for you at an even more fun price.

These wooden star ornaments are handpainted with acrylic paints. The design is different on front and back and include lots of your favorite Pleasant Avenue colorways. The ornaments are strung on strong waxed cotton cord, so they can be enjoyed for years. You can hang them on your trees or adorn gifts and stockings with them. Hang them year round from door knobs or small hooks.

Shipping from United States

Processing time

1-3 business days

Estimated shipping times

  • Canada : 2 - 3 weeks
  • North America : 2 - 10 business days
  • Europe : 2 - 3 weeks
  • Australia, New Zealand and Oceania : 2 - 3 weeks

I'll do my best to meet these shipping estimates, but can't guarantee them. Actual delivery time will depend on the shipping method you choose.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment Options

Secure options
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards

Returns & Exchanges

I gladly accept returns

Just contact me within: 14 days of delivery

Ship items back to me within: 30 days of delivery

I don't accept exchanges or cancellations

But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.

The following items can't be returned or exchanged

Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:

  • Custom or personalized orders

Conditions of return

Buyers are responsible for return shipping costs. If the item is not returned in its original condition, the buyer is responsible for any loss in value.

Frequently Asked Questions

Wholesale availability

Wholesale is now available! Local shops may qualify for extra perks like in-shop appearances and free delivery. Message me for details.

Where's my order?

Cards do not ship with tracking information. Upgrade to U.S. Priority available upon request. Fees apply.

Cards ship USPS first class, which does not include tracking information and delivery widely varies. Typically, an item should arrive within 3-5 business days, but can take up to 10. Before filing a formal case with Etsy, please:

1. Double check the address provided. Buyers sometimes forget to keep an updated address on file or forget an apartment number.
2. Check near your front door. Some packages may not fit in some mailboxes and sometimes postmen will leave them inside your door or under a mat.
3. Check with your local post office. For varying reasons from weather to road construction, the package may still b

What's inside the card?

All cards are blank inside. Personalized messages available by request.

Do you really hand-paint each card?

Yes! All paper goods are made-to-order. No printing here.

Can I return an item?

When requesting a custom order, it is the customer's responsibility to read the custom listing thoroughly. Pleasant Avenue will only replace custom designs that are irreparably damaged in shipping or do not match the product description in the custom listing.

Reviews (1)


I ordered these to hang with stockings, and they’re adorable. I might order more so I can use them on my tree, too! Bright colors and fun patterns. The seller sent them quickly and packed with care. Will definitely order again!

Legal imprint